Bad experience, there was a long wait of mroe than 10 months to get 2 referee reports that did not like the the paper (but not so sure why). The editor picked a new (hostile) referee in the 2nd round. And some more nice words. Fair decision, referee reports pointed out major flaw but hardly in a way that could be called constructive. 1 very good referee reports, 1 mediocre, editor was nice. Department of Economics, Stanford University, Stanford, California (USA) Paper sent to an editor with completely different interests. Very helpful letter from a referee and a coeditor. Referee had positive comments and suggested revise and resubmit, but editor rejected it. One great, very helpful report; one report that made an honest effort, but wasn't useful; one report that was one paragraph long and littered with spelling mistakes. The referee reports were received by the ediotr roughly a month before a decision was made. Received the standard 50% fee refund (wow, so useful), Generic desk reject w/o further information, Desk rejected after about 1 month. Very helpful comments. complete waste of time, Very nice editor's letter. Both refs postive but think the topic is not a good fit for the journal. Worst experience ever. Barro says not sufficiently general interest, and advises to try a field journal instead. Managing the academic job market - Chris Blattman desk rejected after more than 2 months, very generic motivation (try a field journal), they took the submission fees and thanked me a lot for the payment! Complete waste of time.. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series C (Applied Statistics), Reports not very helpful, paper not in journal scope. Took seven weeks to get these reviews, pretty efficient journal. What is up with Econ Job Rumors? : r/academiceconomics - reddit Placements of Recent Economics Graduates. If the editor tought the paper did not fit the scope of the journal, he should have rejected it at the very beginning of the process, without engaging in a peer-review. four reports. Good experience overall.

Mcdonalds Disney Glasses 1990s, Contrast Paints Over Leadbelcher, Articles E